Bethlehem Merch & Gift Ideas 2026

About 235 Results
Price
  • Under $40.00
  • From $40.00 - $80.00
  • From $80.00 - $120.00
  • From $120.00 - $160.00
Most Relevant
  • Best Selling
  • Newest
  • Top View
  • Price: Low to High
  • Price: High to Low
  • Top Discount
Bethlehem T-Shirts Bethlehem Women's Mini Skirts Bethlehem Outerwear Bethlehem Baseball Jerseys Bethlehem Hawaiians Bethlehem Hoodies Bethlehem Sweatshirts Bethlehem Tank Tops Bethlehem Scarves Bethlehem Baby & Toddler Clothing Bethlehem Throw Pillows Bethlehem Garden Flags Bethlehem Shoes Bethlehem Pillows Bethlehem Kitchen & Dining
Bethlehem Pennsylvania Skyline T Shirts

Bethlehem Pennsylvania Skyline T Shirts
$14.95
$20.95
29% OFF
Tags
Pennsylvania Bethlehem
Also search
t, skyline, shirts, pennsylvania, bethlehem
Bethlehem Pennsylvania City Skyline T Shirts

Bethlehem Pennsylvania City Skyline T Shirts
$14.95
$20.95
29% OFF
Tags
Pennsylvania Bethlehem
Also search
t, city, skyline, pennsylvania, bethlehem
star of Bethlehem flower watercolor Polo T-shirt

star of Bethlehem flower watercolor Polo T-shirt
$12.95
$18.95
32% OFF
Tags
Flower Watercolor Bethlehem
Also search
Watercolor, flower, Of, star, bethlehem
Mary and Joseph in Bethlehem with donkey T Shirts

Mary and Joseph in Bethlehem with donkey T Shirts
$12.95
$20.95
38% OFF
Tags
Donkey Bethlehem
Also search
in, and, mary, joseph, bethlehem
Bethlehem Pennsylvania Pa Established Sports T Shirts

Bethlehem Pennsylvania Pa Established Sports T Shirts
$14.95
$20.95
29% OFF
Tags
Sports Pennsylvania Bethlehem
Also search
Sports, pa, established, pennsylvania, bethlehem
Bethlehem Pennsylvania Pa Established Sports T Shirts

Bethlehem Pennsylvania Pa Established Sports T Shirts
$12.95
$20.95
38% OFF
Tags
Sports Pennsylvania Bethlehem
Also search
Sports, pa, established, pennsylvania, bethlehem
Christmas Wise Men Golden Star of Bethlehem T-shirt

Christmas Wise Men Golden Star of Bethlehem T-shirt
$14.95
$20.95
29% OFF
Tags
Men Christmas Bethlehem
Also search
Christmas, men, star, golden, wise
Jesus | Bethlehem Coordinates T Shirts

Jesus | Bethlehem Coordinates T Shirts
$14.95
$20.95
29% OFF
Tags
Jesus Bethlehem
Also search
t, Jesus, shirts, coordinates, bethlehem
Vintage Bethlehem Steel Fan Art T Shirts

Vintage Bethlehem Steel Fan Art T Shirts
$14.95
$29.95
50% OFF
Tags
Art Bethlehem
Also search
Art, bethlehem
The Black Keys 2025 Musikfest Bethlehem PA T-Shirt, Band Concert Tee

The Black Keys 2025 Musikfest Bethlehem PA T-Shirt, Band Concert Tee
$14.95
Tags
Concert Band Black
Also search
Band, concert, The Black Keys, bethlehem
Bethlehem Pennsylvania Pa Established Sports T Shirts

Bethlehem Pennsylvania Pa Established Sports T Shirts
$14.95
$20.95
29% OFF
Tags
Sports Pennsylvania Bethlehem
Also search
Sports, pennsylvania, bethlehem
Truestory Birth Jesus True Bible Story Bethlehem T Shirts

Truestory Birth Jesus True Bible Story Bethlehem T Shirts
$14.95
$29.95
50% OFF
Tags
Jesus Bible Bethlehem
Also search
Jesus, bible, bethlehem
PENNSYLVANIA BETHLEHEM US DESIGNER EDITION T Shirts

PENNSYLVANIA BETHLEHEM US DESIGNER EDITION T Shirts
$14.95
$20.95
29% OFF
Tags
Pennsylvania Bethlehem
Also search
designer, Us, edition, pennsylvania, bethlehem
Josef Maria Jesus Jesus birth Bethlehem Christmas T-shirt

Josef Maria Jesus Jesus birth Bethlehem Christmas T-shirt
$14.95
$20.95
29% OFF
Tags
Jesus Christmas Bethlehem
Also search
Jesus, birth, maria, bethlehem, josef
Mary and Joseph Going to Bethlehem T Shirts

Mary and Joseph Going to Bethlehem T Shirts
$12.95
$20.95
38% OFF
Tags
Bethlehem
Also search
to, and, Going, mary, joseph
Bethlehem Pennsylvania Gay Pride Rainbow Skyline T Shirts

Bethlehem Pennsylvania Gay Pride Rainbow Skyline T Shirts
$14.95
$20.95
29% OFF
Tags
Rainbow Gay Pride Pennsylvania
Also search
pride, rainbow, gay, pennsylvania, bethlehem
Retro 1970's Style Bethlehem Pennsylvania Skyline T Shirts

Retro 1970's Style Bethlehem Pennsylvania Skyline T Shirts
$14.95
$20.95
29% OFF
Tags
Retro 1970S Pennsylvania
Also search
retro, style, 1970s, pennsylvania, bethlehem
Retro Style Bethlehem Pennsylvania Skyline T Shirts

Retro Style Bethlehem Pennsylvania Skyline T Shirts
$14.95
$20.95
29% OFF
Tags
Retro Pennsylvania Bethlehem
Also search
retro, skyline, style, pennsylvania, bethlehem
Bethlehem Sporting Goods T-Shirt Vintage Sportswear Unisex Tee

Bethlehem Sporting Goods T-Shirt Vintage Sportswear Unisex Tee
$14.95
Tags
Bethlehem
Also search
bethlehem
Bethlehem Pennsylvania Shirt My Story Begins Here Flag Design

Bethlehem Pennsylvania Shirt My Story Begins Here Flag Design
$14.95
Tags
Pennsylvania Bethlehem
Also search
pennsylvania, bethlehem
Bethlehem graffiti T-shirt

Bethlehem graffiti T-shirt
$14.95
$20.95
29% OFF
Tags
Graffiti Bethlehem
Also search
t, graffiti, shirt, bethlehem
Bethlehem Pennsylvania Sunset Skyline T Shirts

Bethlehem Pennsylvania Sunset Skyline T Shirts
$14.95
$20.95
29% OFF
Tags
Sunset Pennsylvania Bethlehem
Also search
t, sunset, skyline, pennsylvania, bethlehem
Someone In Bethlehem Pennsylvania Loves Me T Shirts

Someone In Bethlehem Pennsylvania Loves Me T Shirts
$14.95
$20.95
29% OFF
Tags
Pennsylvania Bethlehem
Also search
in, loves, someone, pennsylvania, bethlehem
Retro Style Bethlehem Pennsylvania Skyline T Shirts

Retro Style Bethlehem Pennsylvania Skyline T Shirts
$14.95
$20.95
29% OFF
Tags
Retro Pennsylvania Bethlehem
Also search
retro, skyline, style, pennsylvania, bethlehem
Bethlehem Pennsylvania City Skyline T Shirts

Bethlehem Pennsylvania City Skyline T Shirts
$14.95
$20.95
29% OFF
Tags
Pennsylvania Bethlehem
Also search
t, city, skyline, pennsylvania, bethlehem
Christmas Star over Bethlehem T-shirt

Christmas Star over Bethlehem T-shirt
$14.95
$20.95
29% OFF
Tags
Christmas Bethlehem
Also search
Christmas, t, star, over, bethlehem
Made in Bethlehem Barcode Palestine Flag for Pales Hoodies

Made in Bethlehem Barcode Palestine Flag for Pales Hoodies
$29.95
$69.91
57% OFF
Tags
Bethlehem
Also search
bethlehem
Bethlehem Pennsylvania Pa Established Sports Hoodies

Bethlehem Pennsylvania Pa Established Sports Hoodies
$29.95
$35.96
17% OFF
Tags
Sports Pennsylvania Bethlehem
Also search
Sports, pennsylvania, bethlehem
Mary and Joseph in Bethlehem with donkey Car Seat Covers

Mary and Joseph in Bethlehem with donkey Car Seat Covers
$29.95
$48.95
39% OFF
Tags
Donkey Bethlehem
Also search
donkey, bethlehem
Josef Maria Jesus Jesus birth Bethlehem Christmas Bags

Josef Maria Jesus Jesus birth Bethlehem Christmas Bags
$14.95
$23.95
38% OFF
Tags
Jesus Bethlehem
Also search
Jesus, bethlehem
Blessed Nativity Night Christmas Flag, Snowy Bethlehem Festive Flag, Mary Joseph Jesus Nativity Flag, Star Of Bethlehem Holiday Flag, MYK193

Blessed Nativity Night Christmas Flag, Snowy Bethlehem Festive Flag, Mary Joseph Jesus Nativity Flag, Star Of Bethlehem Holiday Flag, MYK193
$11.95
Tags
Night Jesus Blessed
Also search
blessed, night, Jesus, bethlehem
Christmas Cathedral Night Scene Pillow, Xmas Star Of Bethlehem Pillow, Stained Glass Style Cushion, Snowy Town Pillow Winter Gifts, MYK026

Christmas Cathedral Night Scene Pillow, Xmas Star Of Bethlehem Pillow, Stained Glass Style Cushion, Snowy Town Pillow Winter Gifts, MYK026
$20.95
Tags
Night Christmas Stained Glass
Also search
Christmas, night, stained glass, bethlehem
Brown Man Born In Bethlehem 2 Flowy Cropped Tees

Brown Man Born In Bethlehem 2 Flowy Cropped Tees
$29.95
$36.96
19% OFF
Tags
Brown Cropped Bethlehem
Also search
brown, cropped, bethlehem
Jesus' Bethlehem Coordinates Flowy Cropped Tees

Jesus' Bethlehem Coordinates Flowy Cropped Tees
$29.95
$36.96
19% OFF
Tags
Jesus Cropped Bethlehem
Also search
Jesus, cropped, bethlehem
Bethlehem Pennsylvania Pa Established Sports Flowy Cropped Tees

Bethlehem Pennsylvania Pa Established Sports Flowy Cropped Tees
$28.95
$36.96
22% OFF
Tags
Cropped Pennsylvania Bethlehem
Also search
cropped, pennsylvania, bethlehem
Made in Bethlehem Barcode Palestine Flag for Pales Accent Mugs

Made in Bethlehem Barcode Palestine Flag for Pales Accent Mugs
$12.95
$56.50
77% OFF
Tags
Bethlehem
Also search
bethlehem
Bethlehem Pennsylvania Pa Established Sports Accent Mugs

Bethlehem Pennsylvania Pa Established Sports Accent Mugs
$12.95
$56.50
77% OFF
Tags
Sports Pennsylvania Bethlehem
Also search
Sports, pennsylvania, bethlehem
Bethlehem Pennsylvania Pa Established Sports Accent Mugs

Bethlehem Pennsylvania Pa Established Sports Accent Mugs
$12.95
$56.50
77% OFF
Tags
Sports Pennsylvania Bethlehem
Also search
Sports, pennsylvania, bethlehem
Brown Man Born In Bethlehem 2 Double Sided Tank Tops

Brown Man Born In Bethlehem 2 Double Sided Tank Tops
$18.95
$29.95
37% OFF
Tags
Double Sided Brown Bethlehem
Also search
brown, double-sided, bethlehem
Mary and Joseph in Bethlehem with donkey Double Sided Tank Tops

Mary and Joseph in Bethlehem with donkey Double Sided Tank Tops
$18.95
$29.95
37% OFF
Tags
Donkey Bethlehem
Also search
donkey, bethlehem
Mary and Joseph in Bethlehem with donkey Print Trucker Hats

Mary and Joseph in Bethlehem with donkey Print Trucker Hats
$16.95
$21.95
23% OFF
Tags
Donkey Bethlehem
Also search
donkey, bethlehem
Josef Maria Jesus Jesus birth Bethlehem Christmas Print Trucker Hats

Josef Maria Jesus Jesus birth Bethlehem Christmas Print Trucker Hats
$16.95
$21.95
23% OFF
Tags
Jesus Bethlehem
Also search
Jesus, bethlehem
Made in Bethlehem Barcode Palestine Flag for Pales Tote Bags (AOP)

Made in Bethlehem Barcode Palestine Flag for Pales Tote Bags (AOP)
$17.95
$22.95
22% OFF
Tags
Bethlehem
Also search
bethlehem
Bethlehem Pennsylvania Pa Established Sports Tote Bags (AOP)

Bethlehem Pennsylvania Pa Established Sports Tote Bags (AOP)
$17.95
$22.95
22% OFF
Tags
Pennsylvania Bethlehem
Also search
pennsylvania, bethlehem
Brown Man Born In Bethlehem 2 Tote Bags (AOP)

Brown Man Born In Bethlehem 2 Tote Bags (AOP)
$17.95
$22.95
22% OFF
Tags
Brown Bethlehem
Also search
brown, bethlehem
Jesus' Bethlehem Coordinates Tote Bags (AOP)

Jesus' Bethlehem Coordinates Tote Bags (AOP)
$17.95
$22.95
22% OFF
Tags
Jesus Bethlehem
Also search
Jesus, bethlehem
Bethlehem Pennsylvania Pa Established Sports Tote Bags (AOP)

Bethlehem Pennsylvania Pa Established Sports Tote Bags (AOP)
$17.95
$22.95
22% OFF
Tags
Pennsylvania Bethlehem
Also search
pennsylvania, bethlehem
Bethlehem Pennsylvania Pa Established Sports Tie Dye T Shirts

Bethlehem Pennsylvania Pa Established Sports Tie Dye T Shirts
$18.95
$38.99
51% OFF
Tags
Sports Tie And Dye Pennsylvania
Also search
Sports, pennsylvania, bethlehem, Tie And Dye
Bethlehem Pennsylvania Pa Established Sports Tumblers 40 Oz With Handle

Bethlehem Pennsylvania Pa Established Sports Tumblers 40 Oz With Handle
$29.95
$103.17
71% OFF
Tags
Sports Pennsylvania Bethlehem
Also search
Sports, pennsylvania, bethlehem
Truestory Birth Jesus True Bible Story Bethlehem Tumblers 40 Oz With Handle

Truestory Birth Jesus True Bible Story Bethlehem Tumblers 40 Oz With Handle
$29.95
$103.17
71% OFF
Tags
Jesus Bible Bethlehem
Also search
Jesus, bible, bethlehem
Bethlehem Pennsylvania Pa Established Sports Baseball Jackets

Bethlehem Pennsylvania Pa Established Sports Baseball Jackets
$40.96
$49.95
18% OFF
Tags
Sports Pennsylvania Bethlehem
Also search
Sports, pennsylvania, bethlehem
Bethlehem Pennsylvania Pa Established Sports Blanket Hoodies

Bethlehem Pennsylvania Pa Established Sports Blanket Hoodies
$35.96
$45.95
22% OFF
Tags
Sports Pennsylvania Bethlehem
Also search
Sports, pennsylvania, bethlehem
Josef Maria Jesus Jesus birth Bethlehem Christmas Blanket Hoodies

Josef Maria Jesus Jesus birth Bethlehem Christmas Blanket Hoodies
$35.96
$45.95
22% OFF
Tags
Jesus Bethlehem
Also search
Jesus, bethlehem
Made in Bethlehem Barcode Palestine Flag for Pales Blanket Hoodies

Made in Bethlehem Barcode Palestine Flag for Pales Blanket Hoodies
$35.96
$45.95
22% OFF
Tags
Bethlehem
Also search
bethlehem
Made in Bethlehem Barcode Palestine Flag for Pales Clogs

Made in Bethlehem Barcode Palestine Flag for Pales Clogs
$25.95
$44.54
42% OFF
Tags
Bethlehem
Also search
bethlehem
Bethlehem Pennsylvania Pa Established Sports Clogs

Bethlehem Pennsylvania Pa Established Sports Clogs
$25.95
$44.54
42% OFF
Tags
Sports Pennsylvania Bethlehem
Also search
Sports, pennsylvania, bethlehem
Josef Maria Jesus Jesus birth Bethlehem Christmas Clogs

Josef Maria Jesus Jesus birth Bethlehem Christmas Clogs
$25.95
$44.54
42% OFF
Tags
Jesus Bethlehem
Also search
Jesus, bethlehem
Mary and Joseph in Bethlehem with donkey Clogs

Mary and Joseph in Bethlehem with donkey Clogs
$25.95
$44.54
42% OFF
Tags
Donkey Bethlehem
Also search
donkey, bethlehem
Bethlehem Pennsylvania Pa Established Sports Tumbler With Lid And Straw

Bethlehem Pennsylvania Pa Established Sports Tumbler With Lid And Straw
$18.99
$36.99
49% OFF
Tags
Pennsylvania Bethlehem
Also search
pennsylvania, bethlehem
Made in Bethlehem Barcode Palestine Flag for Pales Tumbler With Lid And Straw

Made in Bethlehem Barcode Palestine Flag for Pales Tumbler With Lid And Straw
$18.99
$36.99
49% OFF
Tags
Bethlehem
Also search
bethlehem

Explore more Bethlehem Collection

Bethlehem Mugs Bethlehem Trucker Hats Bethlehem Ceramic Ornaments Bethlehem Tumblers Bethlehem Car Seat Covers Bethlehem Mineral Wash Tank Tops Bethlehem Blankets Bethlehem Woven Blankets Bethlehem Electronics Accessories Bethlehem Crop Tank Top Bethlehem Tote Bags (AOP) Bethlehem Spiral Notebooks - Ruled Line Bethlehem Bags Bethlehem Flags Bethlehem Decor Bethlehem Linens & Bedding Bethlehem Gradient Glass Mugs Bethlehem Coffee & Tea Cups Bethlehem Bullet Whiskey Glasses
Printblur Explore Bethlehem
Our Happy & Growing Customers
See why people love Printblur
Discover Mary and Joseph Going to Bethlehem T Shirts
Verified Jake H.

Nice! Love the design.

T-shirt looks exactly as shown, comfy fit, and shipped fast. Would buy again!
More
Discover star of Bethlehem flower watercolor Polo T-shirt
Verified JasonW92

Really nice design!

The watercolor stars on the shirt look even better in person. Fits perfectly, totally digging it.
More
Discover The Black Keys 2025 Musikfest Bethlehem PA T-Shirt, Band Concert Tee
Verified JasonM89

Awesome band tee!

Got this shirt today—fits perfectly and the print looks sick. Can’t wait to wear it to the next show!
More
Discover Vintage Bethlehem Steel Fan Art T Shirts
Verified Jake78

Cool design, love it!

The shirt's print is awesome and looks just like the pics. Fits great, super comfy too!
More
Discover Josef Maria Jesus Jesus birth Bethlehem Christmas T-shirt
Verified Emily J.

Cute Christmas tee!

Super soft and comfy! Love the design, looks even better in person. Shipping was quick too :)
More